Eisenhower in War and Peace Read online

  In 1878, the River Brethren sold their holdings along the Susquehanna and moved to Kansas, lured by the promise of cheap land, deep soil, and the opportunity to plant their community in the virgin countryside. They took the train from Harrisburg, filling fifteen freight cars with their farm equipment and belongings, including a dozen heavy-duty eight-horse wagons new to the prairie. They also brought a half-million dollars in cash (roughly $9 million in current dollars), the product of a thrifty lifestyle and successful land sales in a rising eastern market.2 That combination of thrift and capital, of diligence and experience, plus a generous helping of communal support, ensured success where others failed. As an early Kansas history put it, the River Brethren were “one of the most complete and perfectly organized [colonies] that ever entered a new country.”3

  The colony settled in Dickinson County along the fertile banks of Smoky Hill River, smack in the middle of Kansas and twenty miles west of the geographic center of the United States, an area that would become one of the most productive agricultural regions in the world.4 Jacob purchased a quarter section (160 acres) of prime farmland and erected a large house that also served as a Sunday meeting place for the brethren. He built a huge barn reminiscent of the Dutch barns in Pennsylvania, added to his dairy herd, and constructed a wooden windmill.

  The River Brethren thrived in their new setting. Jacob acquired more land, helped found a successful local creamery, and established a bank in the nearby village of Hope. When his children married, he provided each with a quarter section of tillable land as a homestead and two thousand dollars in cash, more than enough to get started if they wished to follow in his footsteps.

  David Eisenhower was fifteen when his parents moved to Kansas. Unlike his siblings he had no interest in farming and secured his father’s permission to study engineering and mechanics at Lane College, a fledgling educational institution founded by the United Brethren in Christ in nearby Lecompton. With a faculty of ten part-time instructors and two hundred students, the school had a modest curriculum emphasizing religious studies and vocational training with a smattering of the liberal arts. David enrolled in September 1883, at the age of twenty, and the following year met a captivating young woman from Virginia, Ida Stover, who had entered Lane to study music.

  Ida’s background was similar to David’s. Her ancestors had emigrated from Swabia (near Stuttgart) a decade before the Eisenhowers, settled initially in Pennsylvania, then in the Shenandoah Valley of Virginia. Among the first Germans to reach the Shenandoah, they prospered tilling the soil and soon accumulated substantial land holdings. Ida was born at Mount Sidney in 1862, one of eleven children, and was baptized in the Lutheran faith. Her parents died when she was young, and she was raised by her maternal grandparents. Blessed with boundless confidence, she left home to attend high school in Staunton, and then taught for two years in a one-room schoolhouse near Mount Sidney. When she turned twenty-one, Ida came into an inheritance of a thousand dollars left by her father. Several of her brothers had already moved to Kansas, and she used part of the money to join them. In June 1883, she settled in Lecompton with her brother William, a successful local minister. That autumn she entered Lane.5

  Ida and David made an attractive couple, but in many ways they could not have been more different. She was optimistic, perky, and, in the words of one biographer, “as bright as the Kansas sunshine.”6 He was solemn, introverted, and stubborn—as humorless and self-absorbed as Ida was vivacious and outgoing. They were married on September 23, 1885, David’s twenty-second birthday, and Ida spent the last of her inheritance, some $600 (roughly $10,000 today), on a new ebony piano built by Hallett and Cumston in Boston, a possession she treasured for the rest of her life.

  David Eisenhower and Ida Stover on their wedding day, September 23, 1885. (illustration credit 1.1)

  Neither David nor Ida completed their studies at Lane. With his father’s support, David opened a general store in Hope, using the proceeds from his wedding present as capital.7 The village of Hope, located twenty-eight miles southeast of Abilene, was the commercial center for the River Brethren. The main line of the Topeka, Salina, and Western Railroad had just reached the settlement, and the opportunity for growth appeared assured. Because David had no business experience, he formed a partnership with Milton Good, a young man roughly the same age who was a clothing salesman in Abilene and who was familiar with the retail trade. There were two apartments above the store. David and Ida lived in one, and the Goods in the other.

  According to Eisenhower legend, Milton Good was a scoundrel who absconded with the firm’s cash, leaving David helpless to pay the store’s bills. The business failed, and David was forced to travel to Denison to find work. That is the account David and Ida told, and which the Eisenhower sons dutifully passed on.8

  That is not what happened. Milton Good did not abscond with the money, and the store did not fail. It had been a rocky partnership from the beginning—the partners were temperamentally mismatched, and David was far from easy to work with. After eighteen months they dissolved the partnership and David bought out Good. He borrowed $3,500 from his father, pledged the store’s inventory as collateral, and used the money to purchase Good’s share of the business. Three days later Jacob Eisenhower canceled the mortgage, in effect converting the loan into a gift.9

  Milton Good’s place in the store was taken by David’s younger brother, Abraham Lincoln Eisenhower, and the firm was rechristened Eisenhower Brothers. Abraham was a River Brethren preacher and practicing veterinarian, and was as genial as David was somber. With Abraham’s spark the business continued, although David grew increasingly dissatisfied. He lost interest in the store and walked away from it in October 1888. The business was renamed A. L. Eisenhower & Company, and David drifted off to Denison, leaving Ida, who was six months pregnant, and their two-year-old son, Arthur, in Abraham’s care.10

  David’s decision to quit the store and abandon his pregnant wife is incomprehensible. He had no job lined up or profession on which to fall back, and he disdained the farm life at which the Eisenhowers excelled. In fact, the decision is so inexplicable that David could never own up to it, and neither parent ever revealed the truth to their children. Out of pity for David, those who knew the truth—the Eisenhower family and others—also kept the secret to themselves, complicit, as it were, in a myth that had no substance. As a result, Ike and his brothers died believing the family’s straitened circumstances were due to Milton Good’s treachery rather than their father’s instability.11

  Ida remained in Hope with Abraham until her second son—christened Edgar, for Edgar Allan Poe—was born, and in April 1889 moved the family to join David in Denison. Eighteen months later Dwight was born. By this time, the family had hit rock bottom. David was twenty-seven, Ida a year older. Of his own volition, David had squandered a substantial inheritance. The Eisenhowers lived in what was little more than a shack beside the tracks. Aside from Ida’s piano (which had been left in Hope), they had no assets other than their clothes and a few household possessions, and absolutely no prospect of doing better.

  The family came to the rescue. In 1891, after the death of his wife, Jacob Eisenhower visited his eldest son in Denison and was visibly shaken by the poverty in which he and Ida were living.12 The Belle Springs Creamery, which Jacob had helped found, and which had become one of the largest and most successful enterprises in Dickinson County, had recently built a new plant in Abilene.13 Chris Musser, David’s brother-in-law (he had married David’s sister Amanda), was the manager of the plant, and Jacob prevailed upon him to find a position for David. Musser offered him a job as a refrigeration mechanic at “less than $50 a month.”14 That is essentially what David was earning in Denison, but the job was a considerable step up from scrubbing the grime from Katy locomotives, and he would be back in the bosom of the family. At Ida’s urging, he accepted immediately. In March 1892, after three and a half years of self-imposed exile, David and Ida returned to Abilene. His total assets, which
he carried in his pocket, amounted to $24.15.

  David and Ida rented a small frame house a few blocks from the creamery. It had no plumbing or electricity, and sat tight by the neighbors with no yard or garden. The Eisenhowers remained there for seven years while three more sons were born: Roy in 1892; Paul in 1894 (he died in infancy); and Earl in 1898. Five boys in a cramped house made life nearly impossible. Again the family came to the rescue. In 1898, David’s brother Abraham sold his veterinary practice (he had sold the store several years earlier) and moved west as a religious missionary. Abraham owned a large two-story frame house set on a three-acre lot, complete with a barn and fruit orchard. He agreed to sell the property to David for a thousand dollars. Jacob advanced the money, and the title was put in Ida’s name—evidently a precaution against a recurrence of David’s wanderlust.15 That is the house in which the Eisenhower boys grew to maturity, and which is now the focal point of the Eisenhower Presidential Library and Museum in Abilene.

  Abilene, Kansas, circa 1900. (illustration credit 1.2)

  The Abilene of 1898 was not the Abilene of Wild Bill Hickok and the Chisholm Trail.b The famous cow town of the 1860s and ’70s had faded into a sleepy Kansas backwater. The streets were still unpaved, the sidewalks still made of wooden planks, and the scent of horse apples still lay over the main street. But the saloons and dance halls were gone. Abilene had but one policeman, who patrolled not for local crime, of which there was none, but for transient hustlers and others of ill repute. Churches, hymn singing, and picnics by the riverbank provided the town’s excitement. Abilene had become a citadel of Protestant fundamentalism, the Kansas cradle of Prohibition. It was one of many buckles on the Bible Belt: a wholesome town of 3,500 where respectable citizens did not profane the Sabbath with baseball or football. The politics were populist, but the lifestyle was as staid and proper as on Boston’s Beacon Hill. It was the American heartland.

  Eisenhower was eight when the family moved to their new home. “I have found out later we were very poor,” he recalled, “but we didn’t know it at the time.”16 David worked twelve hours a day, six days a week at the creamery, but his meager salary scarcely covered basic necessities. Ida ran the household, assigned chores to the children, and managed what became a three-acre garden plot. There were two cows to provide milk, a flock of chickens for eggs, ducks, pigs, and a horse to plow the garden and pull the family wagon. Except for flour, sugar, salt, and kerosene for their lamps, the Eisenhowers were largely self-sufficient. The boys wore hand-me-downs, performed odd jobs around town for spending money, and grew to manhood unencumbered by the complexities of urban life.

  Religion loomed large in the Eisenhower household. The day began with David reading scripture to the family, there were prayers before each meal, and after supper the family gathered again to pass the Bible from hand to hand as each boy read a passage out loud. “This was a good way to get us to read the Bible,” said Ike’s younger brother Milton (who was born in 1899). “I am not sure it was a good way to help us understand it.”17

  None of the Eisenhower brothers shared their parents’ religious ardor. By the time Ike left for West Point he had read the Bible through twice. He was familiar with it and often quoted passages from memory, but he rarely took it literally. His vocabulary was punctuated with profanity that would make a mule skinner blush, and throughout his military service he never joined a church or attended Sunday service.18 As president he allowed himself to be convinced that the United States was a Christian country, joined Mamie in the Presbyterian faith, and urged that the words “under God” be inserted in the pledge of allegiance.19 c Like FDR, a nominal Episcopalian, Eisenhower appreciated religion’s political resonance.

  For their part, David and Ida left the River Brethren and began the search for religious certainty in more personal terms. David found it in the Great Pyramid of Giza, which he reproduced in a six-by-ten-foot scale drawing and which he believed corroborated the prophecies in the Bible. Ida turned to a more austere and primitive sect known as Bible Students, which in 1931 adopted the name “Jehovah’s Witnesses.”20 Ike’s brother Edgar remembers meetings in their house. “Everyone made his own interpretation of the Scripture lessons. Mother played the piano, and they sang hymns before and after each meeting. It was a real old time prayer meeting. They talked to God, read Scriptures, and everyone got a chance to state his relationship with Him.”21 David attended Bible Students meetings with Ida for a number of years and then dropped out, retreating into personal mysticism.

  After his misadventure in Denison, David was chastened and bitter. He became ever more sullen and introspective—something of a stranger to his children, with a quick and fearful temper. David never played with his sons, never took them hunting or fishing, did not swim with them, showed no interest in who their friends were, and rarely inquired about their activities. “He was an inflexible man with a stern code,” said Edgar. “Life to him was a very serious proposition, and that’s the way he lived it, soberly and with due reflection.”22

  The Eisenhower household revolved around David’s needs. Ida accepted his decisions, boosted his ego, and bowed to his whims. “I never heard a cross word pass between them,” Ike remembered.23 The boys took turns getting up before daylight to build a fire in the cookstove to prepare David’s breakfast. They carried his hot lunch to him every day at the creamery, and Ida had dinner prepared when he got home in the evening. David lived in his own world. As Ike’s oldest brother, Arthur, put it, their father was absent even when he was there.24

  Ida took up the slack. “Mother was by far the greatest personal influence on our lives,” said Ike.25 She was there for them when David was not, a constant presence who organized their lives, soothed their hurts, and praised their accomplishments. Despite the near penury in which they lived, Ida could usually see the humorous side of any predicament. Milton said, “She always had a song in her heart.”26 Of all the boys, it was commonly agreed that Ike was the one who resembled his mother most.

  The Eisenhower brothers may not have known that they were poor, but they knew they did not want the menial life their father led. As soon as they could, they put Abilene behind them. Arthur was the first to leave, quitting high school after two years to seek his fortune in Kansas City, where he found employment as a bank messenger.d Beginning at a salary of five dollars a week, Arthur rose through the ranks to become executive vice president and a director of the Commerce Trust, one of the largest banks west of the Mississippi. He became a national expert in the grain trade and, in a fifty-year career with the bank, never missed a day because of ill health.27 “Arthur was a trail blazer for the rest of us,” said Edgar. “He pointed the way upward by being the first to break away to find a job.”28

  The Eisenhower family, 1902. Front: David, Milton, and Ida; back: Dwight, Edgar, Arthur, Earl, and Roy. (illustration credit 1.3)

  Edgar dropped out of school for two years, worked at a series of unskilled jobs at the Belle Springs Creamery, and then returned to graduate from high school with Ike in 1909. He worked his way through Michigan Law School,29 founded his own firm in Tacoma, Washington (Eisenhower, Hunter, Ramsdell, and Duncan), and was the most financially successful of the brothers. Edgar was also the most combative and avuncular, and the most outspokenly conservative. He admired Chief Justice John Marshall, despised Franklin Roosevelt and the New Deal, and deplored the progressive drift of his brother’s presidency.

  Roy, the fourth brother, worked equally hard to succeed as a pharmacist, first in Ellsworth, then in Junction City, Kansas, where he owned his own store. Roy traveled the least distance from Abilene, but his store did a thriving business (Fort Riley was nearby), and he became a fixture in local civic organizations. The most social and outgoing of the brothers—a born joiner and glad-hander—he died of a heart condition in 1942 at the age of fifty.

  Earl, a successful engineer and newspaperman, also left Abilene after high school and joined Edgar in Tacoma. With Edgar’s help he graduated from the U
niversity of Washington in 1923 with a degree in electrical engineering, traveled the Far East as an engineer on the passenger liner President Grant, and settled in western Pennsylvania with a public utility company. Later he worked as general manager for Suburban Life, a biweekly newspaper in La Grange, Illinois, and served one term (1964–66) as a Republican member of the Illinois legislature.

  Milton, nine years younger than Ike, was the scholar in the family. Trained in journalism at Kansas State, he entered government service in 1926 after attaining the highest score on that year’s civil service examination. He rose rapidly in Washington, and by the early 1930s was the principal assistant to Henry Wallace at the Department of Agriculture. In February 1942, when the Army interned Japanese Americans living on the Pacific coast, FDR named Milton to head the War Relocation Authority to handle their resettlement.30 Three months later he became deputy director of the newly established Office of War Information. Milton left government in 1943 to become president of Kansas State University, was named president of Penn State in 1950, and six years later became president of Johns Hopkins.

  If Ike shared his brothers’ urgency to succeed it was not immediately evident. After coasting through high school, he worked for two years at the Belle Springs Creamery, first as an ice puller hoisting three-hundred-pound slabs of ice from the freezing unit, then as a fireman stoking furnaces, and finally as the night superintendent of the plant. His salary of ninety dollars a month was essentially the same as his father’s, who had been employed at the creamery for eighteen years.

  Senior photo of Dwight from the Abilene High School yearbook, 1909. Ike’s classmates voted him most likely to become a history professor at Yale. (illustration credit 1.4)